Tuesday, 12 October 2010

When is a punishment not a punishment? Are some schools confusing behaviour modification with punishment?

Many schools use the system of ‘on report’ for managing individual pupil’s behaviour. This can take several forms, but the most usual is a card or sheet with the day’s lessons in a grid and a space for the teacher to make a comment or mark a grade and sign. Often there will be some sort of target set for the day or week. Most schools will have several types of report, usually at increasing levels of staff seniority: Form Tutor Report, Head of Year Report, SLT or Head Teacher Report, for example. On report can be a very useful tool in modifying pupil behaviour, but I wonder to what extent some staff in schools just miss the point?

A pupil may be put on report following a repeated pattern of transgressions, but on occasion I have seen pupils placed on report following a single, one-off incident. For me this raises the question of what the teacher instigating the report is trying to achieve by this action. In the latter case, and even in the former, it sometimes appears that the report is being used as a form of punishment. Indeed, I’ve even had heads of year say as much; as if the bearing the responsibility and inconvenience of carrying the card round from lesson to lesson was, in itself, a punishment. For me this completely misses the point of being on report. The purpose of being on report should be therapeutic, not punitive. On and off over the period of a year or so I asked pupils in my classes and who were on report two questions: i) ‘ what do think is the purpose of you being on report’ and ii) ‘what happens if you don’t meet your target for the day’. The answer to question one was invariably ‘because I’ve been naughty’. Every single one viewed it as a punishment; not one child replied with any suggestion that there might be some sort supportive or therapeutic purpose to being on report. The response to the second question, what happens if you don’t meet today’s target, the answer was often “nuffink, sir” i.e. there was no sanction for failing to meet the set target for the day. Occasionally a pupil reported a significant consequence for failing to meet a target, e.g. a detention, but the most often reported consequence was simply a warning to ‘do better tomorrow’; in other words, no real consequence at all. There is no point in setting targets at all unless there is either a reward for meeting the target and/or a sanction for not meeting them. On report targets should be:
• based on previous behaviour. E.g. a pupil with a history of being late to lesson may have a target ‘Arrived to lesson on time’.
• Challenging but not unachievable. Setting targets which are too easily met or too difficult to achieve will not help modify the pupil behaviour.
There should also be a clear exit strategy and a final goal in mind when the pupil is put on report. These outcomes, and the purpose of the report (i.e. behaviour modification), should be clearly explained to the pupil at the outset. The report should be for a set period, e.g. a week, and the pupil should know what he needs to do to get off report at the end of the period and what will happen if the targets are not met. Open-ended reporting periods, vague or non-specific targets and lack of incentive for success will generally make placing the pupil on report a waste of time.

Consider this analogy: through my own silly behaviour, I fall over and break my leg. At the hospital the doctor chides me for my stupidity, plasters my leg and sends me off with a crutch. Now I could be resentful that the doctor has punished me by making me carry a damned, awkward crutch around all day, or I could view it for what it is; a support for me to lean on until my leg gets better. How do your pupils view being on report, as a punishment or as an aid to help them improve their behaviour? Understanding the pupil perception of being on report can dramatically affect its efficacy.

11 comments:

  1. I do not support pupils being placed on report following a single incident. They must have commited repeated pattern of transgressions before they are included in the report book.
    This is one of the thing that I have discouraged in the Nigeria Education system.

    ReplyDelete
  2. happy to be able to visit your web ... successful greetings from hargasamsungsmartphone.com
    <Samsung Galaxy S4
    Samsung Galaxy Y
    Samsung Galaxy S 3
    Samsung Galaxy Tab 3

    ReplyDelete
  3. Terimakasih atas infonya sukses selalu
    bagi yang butuh informasi hp Gadget menarik.. lihat aja link disini!!!
    Huawei G8
    Huawei Mediapad T1
    Huawei P8 Lite
    Huawei MateBook

    ReplyDelete
  4. Terimakasih atas infonya sukses selalu
    pilihan wisata di pantai pangandaran.. lihat aja link disini!!!
    Pantai Batu Hiu
    Pantai Karang Nini
    Pantai Karapyak
    Pantai Pangandaran

    ReplyDelete
  5. salam sukses dari lenovo, terima kasih telah diijinkan berkunjung ke situs anda.
    Lenovo K900
    Lenovo A6000
    Lenovo A7000
    Lenovo A369i

    ReplyDelete
  6. thanks was allowed to visit your site. successful greetings from hargasamsungsmartphone.com
    Samsung Galaxy Ace 2
    Samsung Galaxy Grand
    Samsung Galaxy Ace Plus
    Samsung Galaxy S3 Mini

    ReplyDelete
  7. postingan menarik, sangat bermanfaat. Semoga sukses terus. Terimakasih
    info Gadget menarik.
    Oppo F1
    Oppo Neo 7
    OPPO Neo 5
    Oppo Joy 3

    ReplyDelete
  8. thanks was allowed to visit your site. successful greetings from hargasamsungsmartphone.com
    Samsung Galaxy Fame
    Samsung Galaxy Chat
    Samsung Galaxy Grand Prime
    Samsung Galaxy Y Duos

    ReplyDelete
  9. postingan menarik, sangat bermanfaat. Semoga sukses terus. Terimakasih
    info Gadget lenovo menarik.

    Lenovo K900
    Lenovo A6000
    Lenovo A7000
    Lenovo A369i

    ReplyDelete